Independent investigators John Gleason (at microphone) and James Sudler address the media after the Court's ruling, April 10, 2012

From the State Bar of Arizona:

Attorneys Disciplined for Using Positions to Punish Adversaries

PHOENIX – April 10, 2012 – A three member disciplinary panel has ordered attorneys Andrew Thomas and Lisa Aubuchon be disbarred for violating the Rules of Professional Conduct. A third attorney, Rachel Alexander, will be suspended for six months and one day.

The panel found that Thomas and Aubuchon used their positions as Maricopa County attorney and deputy county attorney to target political enemies. A 247-page order details how they ignored conflicts of interest and used their positions to burden and embarrass targeted individuals. The order also states they violated the Rules of Professional Conduct relating to perjury and violating court rules. Alexander, who also worked as a deputy county attorney, was found to have filed a lawsuit without completing a proper factual investigation.

Hon. William O'Neil (left), Presiding Disciplinary Judge, issues the panel's ruling, April 10, 2012

The case was tried over nine weeks before a hearing panel comprised of the Presiding Disciplinary Judge and two volunteer panel members (one attorney and a member of the public). Forty eight witnesses testified and nearly 6,200 pages of exhibits were admitted.

In its ruling, the panel stated, “This case is replete with intentionally orchestrated malignant actions.” It went on to state there was an “absence of ethical behavior.”

The sanctions are scheduled to take effect May 10, 2012. Thomas, Aubuchon and Alexander have 10 days to decide whether they will appeal the rulings to the Arizona Supreme Court. If they choose to do so, they can also request the discipline be stayed until the appeal is heard.

The panel’s final order can be read here.

Presiding Disciplinary Judge William O'Neil, left, announces the disbarment and discipline ruling as panel members attorney Mark Sifferman and Rev. John Hall (on right) listen.